Understanding Removal Defense in Texas Immigration Courts
Facing deportation proceedings in Texas is one of the most frightening experiences for immigrants and their families. The threat of being separated from loved ones and losing your home creates overwhelming stress and uncertainty. Texas, with busy courts in cities like Houston, Dallas, San Antonio, El Paso, and Harlingen, handles more deportation cases than almost any other state. This requires specialized legal defense.
The fundamental answer is clear: Removal Defense in Texas Immigration Courts is possible, but it requires immediate, experienced legal intervention. Many federal laws provide avenues for defending against removal, but success hinges entirely on thorough preparation and expert counsel from a law firm familiar with the local court practices.
The Deportation Process: From NTA to Final Order
Deportation, officially termed removal proceedings, is a civil process initiated by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) that takes place before an Immigration Judge (IJ). Understanding the process is the first step toward building a defense.
1. The Notice to Appear (NTA)
The process begins when you are served with a Notice to Appear (NTA). This document is crucial; it outlines the government's factual allegations against you and the specific legal charges (violations of the Immigration and Nationality Act) that form the basis for your removal.
Never ignore the NTA. Missing a court date results in an automatic deportation order.
The NTA contains critical deadlines. Your lawyer needs this document immediately to identify any errors or flaws in the government's case.
2. The Court Hearings
Removal proceedings involve two types of hearings:
Master Calendar Hearings: These are preliminary status conferences where the Judge explains the charges, advises you of your rights, and asks if you admit or deny the allegations. You must ask the judge for time to find a lawyer if you haven't done so yet.
Individual Hearings (Merits Hearings): This is the actual trial. Your case is heard exclusively, witnesses testify on your behalf, and documentary evidence is presented to support your application for relief (the legal benefit that would allow you to stay).
Grounds for Deportation: Why ICE Initiates Proceedings
Identifying the specific charges against you is vital, as it determines which defenses you can pursue. In Texas, the most common grounds for deportation fall into three categories:
1. Unlawful Entry and Status Violations
This is the most frequent reason for removal proceedings, particularly along the border.
Unlawful Entry: Entering the U.S. without inspection.
Visa Overstays: Remaining in the U.S. beyond the authorized period.
Violation of Status: Failing to follow visa conditions (e.g., working without authorization on a student visa).
2. Criminal Convictions (The Most Severe Risk)
Criminal convictions carry the most serious immigration consequences, often resulting in mandatory detention and severely limited relief options.
Aggravated Felonies: Despite the name, this category includes a wide range of offenses (fraud over $10,000, theft with a sentence of one year, drug trafficking). Conviction often leads to mandatory deportation and a permanent bar from the U.S.
Crimes Involving Moral Turpitude (CIMT): These typically involve offenses related to fraud, theft, dishonesty, or intent to harm. Even a misdemeanor can qualify if it involves dishonesty.
Drug Offenses: Any conviction related to controlled substances (with the minor exception of a single offense of simple possession of 30 grams or less of marijuana) triggers deportability.
3. Reinstatement of Prior Removal Orders
If you have ever been deported before, you generally lose the right to see an Immigration Judge or ask for a bond. Your previous deportation order is typically reinstated, or used to deport you again immediately, unless you can apply for very limited forms of relief like Asylum.
Also Read: Your Work Permit and Deportation: The Unvarnished Truth
Key Legal Defenses Available in Texas Immigration Courts
The right defense strategy depends entirely on your unique facts, your family ties, how you entered, your criminal history, and your fear of returning.
1. Cancellation of Removal (Non-LPR and LPR)
This is one of the most powerful forms of relief, granted by the IJ based on strong equities in the U.S.
Cancellation for Lawful Permanent Residents (LPRs): Requires showing 7 years of continuous residence after admission, 5 years as an LPR, and no aggravated felony conviction.
Cancellation for Non-LPRs: Requires showing 10 years of continuous physical presence, Good Moral Character (GMC), and proving that your qualifying U.S. citizen or LPR relative (spouse, parent, or child) would suffer exceptional and extremely unusual hardship if you were deported.
2. Adjustment of Status
If you are deportable, you can try to become a permanent resident in court if you have an eligible, immediate relative petitioner (U.S. citizen spouse, parent, or child over 21) and a visa is immediately available. This path often requires obtaining waivers of inadmissibility for issues like unlawful presence or fraud.
3. Asylum and Protection under CAT
If you fear persecution in your home country based on your race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group, you can apply for Asylum.
Withholding of Removal and Convention Against Torture (CAT): These forms of relief are available if you cannot meet the higher burden for Asylum but still face a strong probability of torture or persecution.
4. Prosecutorial Discretion
This is a request made to the ICE (DHS) attorney to exercise discretion and agree to dismiss or pause your case. While not a defense, it is a tool used when an immigrant has strong humanitarian factors (long U.S. residence, sick family members, or military service).
You Might be Interested: How to Get a Green Card in Texas Through Family
The Critical Need for Removal Defense in Texas Immigration Courts
Texas courts, particularly those near the border, operate with immense backlogs and fast-moving dockets for detained cases. Statistics consistently show that represented individuals in immigration court succeed at dramatically higher rates than those without an attorney.
Detention and Bond Hearings
If you are detained by ICE (perhaps at the Port Isabel Service Processing Center or the Port of Houston Contract Detention Facility), you may have the right to a bond hearing to argue for your release while your case is pending.
Bond is not guaranteed. Individuals with certain criminal convictions are subject to mandatory detention and cannot be released on bond.
A lawyer argues your equities (ties to the community, lack of flight risk, and eligibility for relief) to the judge, potentially securing your release or a reduced bond amount.
The Power of an Experienced Immigration Lawyer
Removal defense in Texas immigration courts requires more than legal theory, it requires familiarity with the local judges and the opposing ICE counsel. Your attorney's role is to:
Analyze the Charges: Identify legal and procedural errors in the NTA.
Develop a Theory of Relief: Select the strongest defense strategy based on your history and ties.
Gather Evidence: Collect comprehensive supporting documentation (medical records, tax returns, character references) for your application.
Represent You: Negotiate with ICE attorneys and present your case confidently before the Immigration Judge.
The consequences of losing are immediate: a final order of removal.
Attorney Iris Guerra Bravo brings insider knowledge to every case. With over 16 years of public service, including time as a Deputy Chief Counsel and Assistant Chief Counsel at ICE, she understands the priorities and strategies of the federal government. This experience, combined with her deep roots in the Rio Grande Valley, allows her to offer unparalleled removal defense in Texas immigration courts.
Facing deportation? Don't go to court alone. Contact Guerra Bravo Law Firm today for a consultation with an experienced immigration lawyer McAllen TX who understands both defense and prosecution.
